TYLER METRO · CARTHAGE, TX

Independent Insurance Agents Serving Carthage, TX

662 licensed insurance agents serving Carthage and surrounding areas. Compare independent insurance agencies serving Carthage and the surrounding Tyler Metro area, TX.

Showing 662 advisors in Carthage

Shaw Insurance Agency
Jerry Shaw & Patsy Shaw·Lufkin
35 years in business
SpecialtiesHome, auto & property
Highly Rated
CFG Insurance Agency
Henderson
SpecialtiesCommercial
Highly Rated
Confidently Retired Financial Planning
Jarrod Null & Laura Null·Nacogdoches
2 years in business
SpecialtiesLife
Thompson-Hicks Insurance
Tyler
SpecialtiesAuto · Home · Boat · Farm/Ranch
Highly Rated
Dixie Dunavant Insurance
Longview
SpecialtiesAuto
Highly Rated
GIBB Insurance Agency
Gilbert Manning Gibb·Tyler
37 years in business
SpecialtiesAuto
CarriersTravelers · Liberty Mutual
Highly Rated
Debra McCann Integra Insurance Services
Palestine
SpecialtiesAuto · Renters
Highly Rated
Germania Insurance - M&M Insurance Agency & Associates
Center
SpecialtiesHome
Highly Rated
Threlkeld & Company
Tyler
SpecialtiesLife & health · Home, auto & property
Highly Rated
B B Boon Insurance Agency
Linden
SpecialtiesLife & health · Home, auto & property
Highly Rated

Not sure where to start?

Not sure if your Carthage coverage still makes sense?

Take the free 4-minute checkup. We'll match you with the right type of advisor for your specific gaps — then you choose who to talk to.

Free Coverage Review
Jackson-Lloyd Insurance
Longview
SpecialtiesLife & health · Home, auto & property
Bird Dog Insurance Services
Ryan Nash·Tyler
6 years in business
SpecialtiesAuto · Home · Commercial
CarriersTravelers · Liberty Mutual · Germania Insurance
Highly Rated
Texas Discount Insurance Agency
Palestine
SpecialtiesAuto
CarriersTexas Discount Insurance
Highly Rated
Texas Wide Insurance
Tyler
SpecialtiesHome, auto & property
Highly Rated
A-Friendly Insurance Agency
Tatum
SpecialtiesAuto
Highly Rated
Bockmon Insurance
Longview
SpecialtiesHealth · Medicare
Highly Rated
Brownrigg Insurance Agency
Marshall
SpecialtiesLife & health · Home, auto & property
Highly Rated
Bounds Insurance Agency
Walter Bounds·Center
56 years in business
SpecialtiesHome, auto & property
CarriersProgressive · Travelers
Pittsburg Insurance
Pittsburg
SpecialtiesAuto
Shelby Savings Bank
Center
Highly Rated

Insurance in Carthage, TX

Hail Risk · Medium
Flood Risk · Low
Wildfire Risk · Low
Tornado Risk · Medium

General area-level risk indicators based on historical regional weather patterns for this part of Texas — not a property-specific underwriting assessment. Talk to an agent about your address's actual exposure.

Your home in Carthage sits at the intersection of multiple carrier pricing models, and those models rarely agree. One insurer might lean heavily on your roof age and credit-based score, while another weights claims history and distance to the nearest fire station. That's why the same property can generate quotes hundreds of dollars apart—and why the cheapest bid isn't always the one that pays when you need it.

Carthage faces medium hail risk and medium tornado risk, which means wind and hail deductibles here are often percentage-based rather than flat-dollar amounts. A one-percent wind deductible on a home insured for $250,000 puts you on the hook for $2,500 out of pocket after a storm, not the $1,000 you might expect from your auto policy. Carriers price that exposure differently, and some exclude wind entirely on older roofs, leaving you to discover the gap only after shingles are gone.

An independent agent in Carthage walks you through auto, home, and liability coverage as a single picture, not three separate transactions. They compare carriers side-by-side so you see where one offers broader wind coverage and another cheaper auto rates, then flag the gaps that matter—flood exclusions, umbrella underlying limits, whether your liability follows you when you borrow a friend's truck. That work happens before the claim, when it still makes a difference.

Further reading

Finding an Agent
How Insurance Agents Get Paid — and What That Means for the Advice You're Getting
Most people have no idea how their insurance agent is compensated. Understanding it doesn't mean distrusting your agent — it means being a more informed consumer.
Home & Property
How Long Does an Insurance Claim Take in Texas?
Simple claims may resolve in a few weeks. Complicated claims can take months. Here's what the law requires — and what to do if your insurer isn't moving fast enough.
Auto
Texas Auto Insurance: What Your Policy Actually Covers — and What It Doesn't
A complete 2026 guide for Texas drivers

Related searches in Carthage, TX

Frequently asked questions